Social psychology and the Godfather Film: The curious case of in-groups and out-groups - Udit Batish

In-groups and out-groups are social categories people use to define themselves and others. An in-group is a social group to which an individual feels they belong, while an out-group is a group to which they feel they do not belong. These distinctions lead to social categorisation and stereotypes. 

When studying the concept of in-groups and out-groups in class, I couldn't help but think about this in the context of one of my favourite films - The Godfather. At the start of the film, Michael Corleone's initial position as an out-group member within the Corleone family stems from his intentional distancing from the family business. Despite the family's close-knit nature, Michael wanted to forge his path as a Marine and war hero far separated from the mafia business. Vito Corleone, the patriarch, also wanted Michael to stay out of the family business by hoping he would become a senator. The family's perception of Michael as an out-group member shifts as circumstances force him to reconsider his position. The attempt on Vito's life and later events force Michael into a more active role within the family, challenging the initial out-group categorisation. As the story progresses, Michael's transformation from an outsider to a central figure in the family business becomes the key theme in the film. 

Michael himself undergoes a profound shift from an out-group stance, where he distances himself from the family to an in-group perspective, actively accepting his role in the family's actions. This shift becomes evident through various clues. One significant clue is the growing emotional and physical distance he creates between himself and Kay-his girlfriend. This distance can be seen as a means to evade her scrutiny, recognising that his involvement with the family is intensifying. In another one of my favourite scenes, Michael stands outside a hospital and there are a few enemy gunmen nearby. The scene placed an emphasis on Michael's steady hands while lighting a cigarette in a tense situation, which serves as a visual cue. This seemingly small action becomes essential as it highlights Michael's realisation that he can face danger without fear and no longer considers himself a "civilian" in the mafia business.

As an in-group member, Michael experiences a shift in his self-concept. Michael's honesty gives way to moral ambiguity to achieve vengeance for the shooting of his father, and he more and more becomes what he initially despised in order to fit in better with his family and their interests. For a man who always viewed himself as something of a prodigal son, he is now deeply ingrained in the family business. His life has a renewed sense of meaning after he expresses his loyalty to his family through sacrifice when he wants to gun down the corrupt police captain. This change tells us a lot about the fluidity of social categorisation and the impact of circumstances on one's perception of these groups. external events and crises can shape how individuals perceive themselves and their social groups. This is also a narrative of personal growth. It shows how individuals can evolve, both in their understanding of themselves and their relationships with others. This growth is not always linear and may involve complex negotiations between personal values, family expectations.

Comments

  1. Great Read @Udit Batish!, Having written about another book titled 'The Perks of Being a Wallflower', it has recently dawned on me that there is a lot of potential to analyze media through a social psychological lens. The basic concepts of in-group and outgroup are valid everywhere, even in our daily lives! Michael's journey in The Godfather these concepts and their nuanced dynamics of in-groups and out-groups, revealing the transience of social categorization.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great read Udit! Your post on the concept of in-groups and out-groups in the context of The Godfather, an iconic movie and a personal favorite, is well-argued and insightful.
    You are spot on when you say that Michael's change is both a story of personal growth and moral uncertainty. It seems like he's getting more cruel and cunning as he works the family business more. However, another thing that changes his life is that he now has a new sense of purpose and relationship.
    Here is one additional thought. The role of context: The circumstances Michael finds himself in have a significant impact on his development. Michael must negotiate a complex and dangerous world ruled by the Corleone family. He feels pressured to conform to family expectations, even if it means surrendering his ideals.
    For anyone interested in the psychoanalysis of this movie, this blog is definitely an offer which they can't refuse!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well articulated and eye opening! Having watched Godfather recently, the discussion in class and this blog made me realise how it masterfully portrays the dynamics of groups and out-groups. The Corleone family embodies a tight-knit in-group, fiercely loyal and protective. Their strength lies in exclusivity, forging a powerful bond while creating a distinct divide from the out-groups, notably other mafia families. This in-group/out-group dynamic is central to the narrative, emphasizing loyalty, trust, and the consequences of crossing these boundaries. The film skillfully showcases the psychological and social complexities of these divisions, shedding light on the consequences, conflicts, and loyalties that arise within these distinct groupings, painting a vivid picture of the intricacies of belonging and exclusion.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like to think of Michael's transformation as a real-life example of the "it takes one to know one" phenomenon. After all, it's only after he becomes deeply involved in the family business that he truly understands what it means to be a Corleone:)...

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How Milgram’s experiment still holds true in the modern day - Arnav Gupta