How Milgram’s experiment still holds true in the modern day - Arnav Gupta
In 1961, Stanley Milgram, a psychologist at Yale University, conducted an experiment focusing on the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience. He was interested in finding out the willingness of people, hailing from a diverse set of backgrounds, to obey an authority figure who instructed them to perform acts conflicting with their personal conscience.
Milgram, a
Jew by birth, wanted to understand the actions of the Nazis who claimed to be
acting under the guise of a supreme leader by just “following orders” during
the Holocaust. The experiment design was fairly simple but almost disturbing: Participants
called ‘teachers’ were led to believe that they were administering electric
shocks to ‘learners’. The teachers quiz the learners and every time the learner
answered wrong, those on Milgram’s team (called ‘experimenters’) would instruct
the teacher to give the learner an electric shock. These fatal shocks gradually
increased to levels that would have been fatal had they been real.
The
findings of the experiment were surprising to most of us, with 65% of the
respondents who administered the experiment’s final massive 450-volt shock,
acting sheerly out of ‘obedience’ and authority of the experimenter. The
conclusion being drawn out is that Ordinary people are likely to follow orders
given by an authority figure, even to the extent of killing an innocent human
being. Obedience to authority is
ingrained in us all from the way we are brought up.
Although
Milgram’s experiment is not perfect in a lot of senses, but a lot of parallels
can be drawn out of this experiment to real-world examples we see today. Although it is the general consensus is that
an event like the Holocaust would not happen today, Milgram’s experiment and
current events (albeit at a much smaller scale) suggest a more morbid truth.
Consider the treatment of Uyghur Muslims in China, the massacres happening
almost daily in Syria or even closer to home, and the growing divide between
religions: what we see is that an ordinary person is able to inflict harm on others,
under the guise of obedience from a higher authority. Through this, one is able
to transfer responsibility for their actions to that said higher authority.
So what can
be done? Is humanity doomed to follow the orders of the next majoritarian dictator?
Recent studies suggest that people don’t inflict harm because they are unaware
of doing wrong but because they believe what they are doing is right. So, the
Nazis acted this way because they were personally motivated to do so.
What is the
key takeaway for us as students then? On a personal note, I feel all this
stresses the importance of having a conscience. One should, in all their daily
lives, be ready to differentiate between what is correct and always be
cognizant of their moral values. We should always be ready to ‘draw a line’ and
always stand up for what is not correct according to this line. For me, this is
a great takeaway that I have applied in my daily life.
Relevant
Links:
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0959354315601904
https://thewire.in/society/social-psychologys-experiments-india-new-majoritarianism
https://www.theguardian.com/science/blog/2011/sep/01/stanley-milgram-research-zealots-zombies
The concept of obedience and conformity can not be understood without this milgram's experiment!!
ReplyDeleteGives an idea how obedience can lead a person from one character to another complete different character
Amazing! I like how the blog is concluded with a beautiful takeaway. It's a subtle point to make yet one of the most important ones. Although being cognizant of our values and standing up for them are both difficult in their own ways for many people. People who conflict-avoidant usually would find it extremely hard to stand up and take action. Similarly, at times students would be influenced by others to an extent where it's hard for them to fall back to their moral principles. Thus factors like proper frameworks, collaborative mechanisms also should exist in place to tackle this problem. Thank you for putting out the point so aptly that one realises where most work needs to take place and we as a society can initiate the change.
ReplyDeleteAn interesting and well-written blog! I like how you have highlighted the significance of morality and conscience. Everyone must discern good from evil and have a strong conscience. We should all be ready to fight authority figures to defend our principles and values.
ReplyDeleteMilgram's experiment demonstrated that even "normal" people may injure others when given instructions to do so by a superior. This teaches us that we need to be skeptical of directives and ready to challenge superiors when called upon rather than obey them all the time.
Arnav's reflection on Milgram's experiment is both insightful and thought-provoking. Drawing parallels to modern-day events, it's a stark reminder of the potential consequences of blind obedience to authority. The emphasis on personal conscience and the call to stand up for what is morally right resonate deeply. It is a powerful read urging us to be vigilant and conscious of our actions in a world where authority can sometimes overshadow morality.
ReplyDelete